Историческая экспертиза

@istorex_ru · news · Russian · active

Subscribers 4K Subscribers, last 30 days: 4K → 4K +0 24h
Reach per post (ERR) 12.9%517 avg views
Posting 7.8/day last 46 minutes ago
Reactions per 1K views 18.0 👍 ❤ 🤡

15. ‘That Holiest-of-Holies Holocaust of the Jews’* Download for free: https://www.istorex.org/post/serguey-ehrlich-memory-identity-and-imagination *The quotation is from the satirical novel My Holocaust by Tova Reich (2009: 282). The author mockingly represents a range of public discourses regarding the Holocaust—nationalistic, cosmopolitan, denying, trivializing, sacralising, and others. Reich’s provocative ‘shock therapeutic’ approach demonstrates that the prophetic tradition of self-criticism remains alive among Jewish intellectuals. This is akin to Viktor Shklovsky’s concept of ‘defamiliarization’ (остранение), which allows us to scrape off the rust of ritual veneration and see anew, that much-vaunted memory of the Holocaust is in deep crisis. A crucial example of global memory is the memory of the Holocaust (Assmann, 2010a). There is an important reason why it can effectively serve as an ‘engine’ for the growing compassion toward all victims of world history—victims who are traditionally regarded as ‘strangers’ within the framework of the modern nation-state heroic narrative. For two thousand years, Jews were paradigmatic ‘strangers’ to Christians, who believed that adherents of Judaism ‘crucified Jesus’ and were therefore their ‘natural enemy.’ Overcoming this entrenched ‘primordial’ pattern of anti-Semitism by instilling empathy for victims of the Holocaust amounts to μεθάνοια (spiritual conversion) for some three billion people across Europe, the Americas, Australia, Northern Asia, and Central and Southern Africa. From this perspective, the memory of the Holocaust is a promising first step in constructing a global memory that should entail compassion for an ever-expanding circle of victims. The worldwide spread of Christianity is the main argument against Stef Craps’s (2019) opinion that the ‘local’ Western context is an obstacle to using the concept of the Holocaust as a model for global memory, on the grounds that non-Western peoples might view it as an imposition of neo-colonial hegemony. In this case, ‘locatedness’ is less important than the pattern of unprecedented empathy toward former paradigmatic ‘strangers.’ Transforming ‘strangers’ into ‘our own’ is one of the greatest achievements of humankind’s morality. The simple mnemonic formula, ‘All victims of world history are our own,’ extends beyond the Western ‘region of memory’ not only because of the reality of Western cultural hegemony, but primarily because this moral pattern is universally applicable to all victims of persecution. I believe that ‘locatedness’ is not the principal obstacle to using the memory of the Holocaust as a global pattern of empathy, and I agree with Valentina Pisanty, who points to another challenge: the contradiction between the global framework and attempts to establish the Holocaust as ‘uniquely unique’ (Eckhardt, 1974: 34), that is, ‘qualitatively different from all other massacres in history’ (Pisanty, 2021: 97). This assumption supported by agents of Israeli governmental institutions, international Jewish organizations, and a significant portion of Western academics and intellectuals, inevitably leads to the following conclusion: ‘To make of the murdered Jews … metaphors for all humanity … is not to exalt but to degrade them’ (Alexander, 1980: 48). This is not Alexander’s personal view. In 2019, the U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum released a Statement Regarding the Museum’s Position on Holocaust Analogies, which ‘unequivocally rejects efforts to create analogies between the Holocaust and other events, whether historical or contemporary’ (Bernstein, 2019).[ ] It should not be taken for granted that the argument of ‘incomparability’ of Nazi genocide of the Jewish people with other genocides of world history is effective in strengthening ethnic Jewish identity. It is certainly not applicable to the construction of global memory, simply because every community values the sufferings ‘that we are experiencing ourselves as more important than distant sufferings. … One of the greatest moral challenges of our World is the ability to place ourselves in others’ shoes, but it is not surprising that we all have difficulties doing that’ (Olick, 2018). It is impossible to overcome this ‘moral challenge of our world’ if we divide victims into ‘ours’ and ‘others,’ assuming that our ones are more significant. The concept of ‘incomparability’ is an embodiment of perverted nationalistic pride that incites enmity among nations. Therefore, it is unclear what goal my ‘stiff-necked’ fellows seek to achieve when they declare to other nations: ‘Our sufferings are incomparably more painful than yours?’ Perhaps it is to protect the Jewish people in a challenging world where far-right xenophobic movements are gaining popularity? However, current political trends do not indicate that the ‘incomparability’ pattern is effective in addressing this problem. I believe that the attempt to establish the ‘superiority in sufferings’ is a form of ethnic arrogance toward non-Jewish people. For instance, how should Japanese people react to the reflections of the author who coined the term ‘uniquely unique’ Holocaust: ‘When thousands[ ] of Japanese were killed and maimed in Hiroshima and Nagasaki, there was a goal behind the acts, a goal variously identifiable as resistance to aggression, restoring of peace, or whatever. … Such historical and contemporary examples possess, at best, only superficial resemblances to anti-Semitism. In contrast to them, the destruction of Jewry is subject to no purpose beyond itself’ (Eckhardt, 1974: 33). The claim for ‘exclusiveness’ can have only one outcome: growing resentment against Jews. In this context Valentina Pisanty raises the question that Michael Rothberg (2021: 7) formulates in the preface to her book: ‘Has a much-vaunted cosmopolitan Holocaust memory—with its linked slogans of “Never forget!” and “Never again!”—simply failed to prevent the rise of the right or, more darkly, might it even be implicated in that political turn?’ I do not agree that the concept of ‘cosmopolitan Holocaust memory’ has failed. In my opinion, a narrow nationalistic—and far from ‘cosmopolitan’— concept of the ‘uniquely unique’ Holocaust has ‘failed to prevent the rise of the right.’ In contrast, the proper use of Holocaust memory as a global engine of empathy for all victims of world history is genuinely effective. We can see that global recognition of the Holocaust stimulates the emergence of new ‘icons’ in global memory, including victims of capitalist colonialism and the communist Gulag, of numerous wars and genocides, of state terror and mass starvation, and more (Giesen, 2004; Rothberg, 2009; Zwigenberg 2014). Therefore, ‘the ability to place ourselves in others’ shoes’ should become the defining feature of the global memory of the Holocaust. Global identity is formed through the gradual understanding that there are no victims who are ‘not our own.’ Within the framework of global memory, no hierarchy of victims should exist; all victims of violence must be equal and ‘our own.’ Bernhard Giesen (2004: 3, italics added) defines this regime of memory—where ‘the victims assume the position that, before, was the place of heroes’—as ‘a new universalism of mourning.’ This ‘politics of regret’ (Olick, 2007)[ ] presents a real challenge to the ethics of the nation-state, which is based on the narrative of the heroic myth and prescribes the sacrifice of ‘strangers’ for the sake of ‘our own.

Views over time

020040028 Oct 02:3311 Nov 13:1639528 Oct 02:33: 0 views11 Nov 13:16: 395 views
Snapshots we took after posting.
WhenViews
28 Oct 2026, 02:330
11 Nov 2026, 13:16395

Who shared this post

Posts in other channels we index that link to this one. (Forwards with a hidden source can't be traced.)

Nobody yet.