12. The Dead End of Modernity Download for free: https://www.istorex.org/post/serguey-ehrlich-memory-identity-and-imagination Benedict Anderson (2006 [1983]), Ernst Gellner (1983), Eric Hobsbawm and Terence Ranger (2013 [1983]) argue that the nation-state is a product of Modernity, arising in the nineteenth century yet proclaiming itself to be a ‘primordial’ (ancient) reality. However, the idea that capitalism is also a phenomenon of the nineteenth century lies beyond the scope of their research. Martin Albrow (1996: 28–51) contends that the nation-state is not only closely connected to capitalism, but that the two are like the Siamese twins—different sides of the same process of modernization, in which the ‘free market’ of low-profit economy serves as a deceptive cover for the inseparable ‘anti-market’ (Braudel, 1983: 230) tandem of state power and big money. Manuel De Landa (2000: 48) suggests redefining the term ‘capitalism’ to include the ‘power to manipulate markets’ as ‘a constitutive part of its meaning.’ It is literally a military-industrial complex. A capitalist economy cannot function without the police, the army, and other ‘militarized’ state institutions that promote the interests of tycoons both inside and outside of the nation-state’s borders. Unlike the nation, which is obsessed with its ancient roots, capitalism is more attuned to its potential longevity in the future. In my opinion, the fact that such phenomena of Modernity as the nation-state and capitalism are transitory is sufficient to show that they have generated problems that cannot be solved within their frameworks. The nuclear threat, environmental degradation, and growing inequality are at the forefront of many global challenges, for which the nation-state and capitalism cannot provide adequate solutions: (1) Russian and Western scholars alike claim that there will be no winners in a nuclear war (Robock et al., 2007). It is pointless to develop more effective anti-missile systems, as humanity would perish regardless of where nuclear explosions occur. Even if the leaders of nuclear powers have enough sense not to use these weapons, there is a high probability that terrorists could acquire them. Ralph Lapp (1970: 177–178), a physicist who had worked on the Manhattan Project, stated in 1970: ‘If a weapons system could be made, then it would be made.’ As human technologies ‘gained the power to erase the human race, scientists began to question whether humans really had control over it’ (Mir, 2025). Despite this, the development of ever more powerful weapons of mass destruction continues. Security is a false pretext for the current arms race; the real motivation lies in the profits earned by arms manufacturers, who have traditionally maintained close ties with governments. (2) Nuclear weapons could destroy humankind in an instant, whereas the environmental threat is less obvious and therefore potentially even more dangerous. The main driver of environmental degradation is the race for conspicuous consumption, which is fueled by the expanded reproduction required by capitalist economies. ‘Today, we are surrounded everywhere by the conspicuousness of consumption through the multiplication of objects and material garb’ (Connerton, 2009: 122). The current ‘consuming cult’ provokes various damaging consequences, such as fashion—that is, the coercion of public opinion to throw away good clothes and other items —or the planned obsolescence of appliances that break down soon after the warranty expires (Bisschop et al., 2022). Satisfying needs based on conspicuous consumption leads to the exhaustion of irreplaceable resources, disastrous environmental pollution, and a massive waste of public time and energy. Environmental pollution does not respect national boundaries: we may take care of the ecology in our own country, but if water, soil, and air are polluted in other parts of the planet, the devastating consequences will affect all of humanity . (3) Growing inequality is related to the fact that the modern technological development enables the replacement of almost all routine operations, so-called ‘labor,’ by machines and artificial intelligence. In a society based on the formula ‘goods—money—goods,’ technological progress is perceived not as the liberation of humanity from hard labor, but as a tragic loss of jobs, prompting the need to develop ‘successful strategies to cope with artificial intelligence’ (Inglehart, 2018: 216, italics added). The modern ‘Luddite’ conflict is articulated as ‘robots against workers’ (Byhovskaya, 2017). Within the frameworks of the nation-state and capitalism, it is impossible to overthrow the Social Darwinian ideology according to which the right to creative activity is reserved for selected ‘Eloi,’ while the masses of ‘Morlocks’ (Herbert G. Wells) are doomed to labor that has become meaningless under new technological conditions (Graeber, 2018).