11. The Deception of the Heroic Myth Download for free: Ehrlich Serguey Memory, Identity, and Imagination. The Structure of Behaviour from the Perspective of Memory Studies. Discussion: Sergei Beliakov, Stefan Berger, Evgeny Blinov, Marianne Hirsch, Ludmila Isurin, Natalija Majsova, Milica Popović, Ann Rigney, Henry L. Roediger III and Olivia L. Jäggi, Marie-Laure Ryan, James V. Wertsch, and Tyler Wertsch. — Chișinău: The Historical Expertise, 2026. 248 p. 978-3-68959-774-0 ISIA Media Verlag https://www.istorex.org/post/serguey-ehrlich-memory-identity-and-imagination In the epoch when agriculture (the food-producing economy) became the necessary foundation of the state, the heroic myth (myth of other-sacrifice) was brought to the fore by the ‘priests,’ who acted as proxies for the so-called ‘people of exploit’ (Thorstein Veblen)—that is, barbaric warriors who dominated early state societies. The identity-solidarity-altruism of this myth unites more people than does the fairy tale. In the era of ancient and medieval states, the ‘national’ identity of the heroic myth was predominantly intrinsic to members of the sacral and military elite (Hroch, 2020: 9) and ‘they evince no interest in disseminating their ethnic culture to outlying groups or lower strata’ (Smith, 1999: 192). It was even common to stress the foreign origin of the upper strata of medieval monarchies, which differentiated them from the non-noble population. During industrial Modernity, the identity of the heroic myth became much broader and came to encompass all citizens of the nation-state. Establishing national identity took a long time; despite the strenuous efforts of intellectuals ‘the peasantry refused to exchange local memory for national memory almost until the First World War’ (Gillis, 1994: 8–9). To establish national identity, the politics of memory shifted ‘the focus from individual heroes to the heroification of entire groups’ of compatriots, because ‘the nation is in all its citizens and the commonality of all its citizens is the nation’ (Giesen, 2004: 27, 33). The ethics of the heroic myth has a dual nature. In relation to ‘our own’ it is altruistic, as it teaches the sacrifice of one’s life for the sake of ‘one’s people.’ But it is not only love for ‘ours,’ it also includes ‘fear and hatred for the foreigner whether he is interior, whether he is exterior’ (Maurras, 1921: 128). Therefore, in relation to ‘strangers’ it can become even more hostile than the ethics of the fairy tale, since the purpose of the heroic myth is to sacrifice (kill) the enemy. ‘Political memory’ (Jan Assmann) is the core of mnemonic practices for agrarian society elites and industrial society citizens. It subsequently becomes deeper: according to the earliest chronicles, in traditional societies, political memory extended to the state’s founders; during Modernity, memory has referred to archaeological sources and occasionally reaches back to the Paleolithic era in search of a nation’s origins. The heroic myth is a clear example of manipulation through the ‘false consciousness’ (Friedrich Engels) of ideology. Agents of national memory ‘teach citizens patriotic lessons about sacrificing personal comforts, or even their lives, for the good of the nation’ (Isurin 2022: 12). The citizen must paradoxically sacrifice himself ‘on behalf of the nation’ regardless of his own interests (Hroch, 2020: 16): ‘He wants his nation to acquire territories, to be prosperous and to have powerful allies; but he wants all this far less on account of the material results … than on account of the glory, the prestige which the nation will acquire’ (Benda, 2011: 14).