🇮🇷🇺🇸Iran war prompts US strategists to propose scaling back Indo-Pacific military presence US security analysts are now weighing a once-unthinkable shift: pulling forces from the first island chain in the Western Pacific Ocean to the second. The First and Second Island Chains are strategic island arcs in the Pacific, running from Japan through Taiwan and the Philippines, and farther east through Guam and Micronesia, respectively. The Quincy Institute’s scholars argued on October 23 that withdrawing US forces to the Second Island Chain would be a strategic folly. More intriguing, however, is that the opposing view is backed by Jennifer Kavanagh, former director of RAND’s Army Strategy program. In an extensive report for Defense Priorities, Kavanagh outlined a US military strategy centered on the Second Island Chain in Asia, proposing to: ➡️ Withdraw most US forces from Taiwan, South Korea, the Philippines and Japan, where they remain vulnerable in a potential conflict with China ➡️ Replace treaty alliances with South Korea, the Philippines and Australia with ad hoc partnerships, and end the US commitment to Taiwan ➡️ Scale back nuclear guarantees, including protection under the US nuclear umbrella ➡️ Shift the strategic focus to the Compact of Free Association (COFA) states – Palau, Micronesia and the Marshall Islands – and Guam ➡️ Deploy unmanned aerial and maritime vehicles ➡️ Phase in the changes over three to eight years, completing most by 2030 and all by 2035 Kavanagh argued that US interests require only a modest regional air and naval presence, viewing the 90,000 troops stationed near China – including 55,000 in Japan and 25,000 in South Korea – as a costly vulnerability. Given her longstanding ties to RAND and the US foreign policy establishment, her proposal may reflect an emerging strategic rethink following the Iran war, which devastated US military bases in the Gulf. 👍 Substack | Chat | @geopolitics_prime